Claims

The value-conflict taxonomy is applied to student rating of teaching at the University of Salzburg, surfacing conflicts such as bandwidth vs. fidelity

Claim · All claims
Evidence · 1 study · theoretical r2 · q1
Currency · newest study 2004 · not yet checked against its sources · not reviewed by a person
Evidence quality · No study behind this claim is a peer-reviewed article with a DOI: it rests on a source with no registered publication record (a web page, book or unpublished report). It is kept because 3 design pages cite it; treat it as a lead to check, not an established finding.

Subclaims

Reading the evidence codes

q is the design tier, i the impact, n the sample, and the kind with its r the rigour judged within that kind: what each code means.

This claim: no standardized effect is recorded in observations/ for it yet, so no benchmark reading is possible.

q1 i? The taxonomy of conflicts between the six value areas is applied to the concrete evaluation process of student rating of teaching at the University of Salzburg, where conflicts such as bandwidth vs. fidelity and student ratings vs. evaluation are discussed. → Patry 2004

Evidence

Patry 2004

Patry, Jean-Luc, & Gastager, Angela. (2004). Kokybės vertinimo dilemos – Dilemmas in quality assessment. The Quality of Higher Education 2004/1. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ874233

q1 · i? · theoretical · r2

The article applies the taxonomy to the Salzburg student-rating project (Task Force "Evaluation von Lehrveranstaltungen an der Universität Salzburg", 2002), discussing named conflicts including bandwidth vs. fidelity and cheating teachers. This is an illustrative application, not a controlled study.

"/G74/G61/G78/G6F/G6E/G6F/G6D/G79/G20/G6F/G66/G20/G63/G6F/G6E/G66/G6C/G69/G63/G74/G73/G20/G62/G65/G74/G77/G65/G65/G6E/G20/G74/G68/G65/G73/G65/G20/G76/G61/G6C/G75/G65/G73/G20/G69/G73/G20/G61/G70/G70/G6C/G69/G65/G64/G20/G74/G6F/G20/G61 /G63/G6F/G6E/G63/G72/G65/G74/G65/G20/G65/G76/G61/G6C/G75/G61/G74/G69/G6F/G6E/G20/G70/G72/G6F/G63/G65/G73/G73/G2C/G20/G6E/G61/G6D/G65/G6C/G79/G20/G74/G68/G65/G20/G73/G74/G75/G64/G65/G6E/G74/G20/G72/G61/G74/G69/G6E/G67/G20/G6F/G66 /G74/G65/G61/G63/G68/G69/G6E/G67/G20/G61/G74/G20/G74/G68/G65/G20/G55/G6E/G69/G76/G65/G72/G73/G69/G74/G79/G20/G6F/G66/G20/G53/G61/G6C/G7A/G62/G75/G72/G67/G2E/G20/G53/G6F/G6D/G65/G20/G6F/G66/G20/G74/G68/G65/G20/G63/G6F/G6E/G66/G6C/G69/G63/G74/G73 /G61/G72/G65/G20/G64/G69/G73/G63/G75/G73/G73/G65/G64/G2C/G20/G65/G2E/G67/G2E/G20/G62/G61/G6E/G64/G77/G69/G64/G74/G68/G20/G76/G73/G2E/G20/G66/G69/G64/G65/G6C/G69/G74/G79/G2C/G20/G69/G6E/G64/G69/G76/G69/G64/G75/G61/G6C/G20/G76/G73/G2E/G20/G73/G6F/G63/G69/G61/G6C /G61/G6E/G64/G20/G63/G72/G69/G74/G65/G72/G69/G6F/G6E/G20/G6F/G72/G69/G65/G6E/G74/G65/G64/G20/G72/G65/G66/G65/G72/G65/G6E/G63/G65/G20/G6E/G6F/G72/G6D/G2C/G20/G73/G74/G75/G64/G65/G6E/G74/G20/G72/G61/G74/G69/G6E/G67/G73/G20/G76/G73/G2E /G65/G76/G61/G6C/G75/G61/G74/G69/G6F/G6E/G2C/G20/G61/G6E/G64/G20/G63/G68/G65/G61/G74/G69/G6E/G67/G20/G74/G65/G61/G63/G68/G65/G72/G73/G2E"

Discussion

Page metadata
Field Value
type claim
id taxonomy-applied-salzburg-student-ratings
title The value-conflict taxonomy is applied to student rating of teaching at the University of Salzburg, surfacing conflicts such as bandwidth vs. fidelity
description The value-conflict taxonomy is applied to student rating of teaching at the University of Salzburg, surfacing conflicts such as bandwidth vs.
status review
evidence_strength weak
newest_evidence 2004
generated by process:wiki-ingest on 2026-09-26
trust unverified — no one has confirmed this page's content
sources 1 — patry-2004

Frontmatter is the page's machine-readable record — see the Schema & Guide.